Skip to content

Councillor says council, not staff, to blame for budget increase starting at 3.93 per cent

Ward 1 councillor Dan Gibson says Sunday twitter back-and-forth with the Mayor not a sign of any 'misalignment,' just healthy discussion
20181217 council gibson ts 9
Ward 1 councillor Dan Gibson. Tony Saxon/GuelphToday file photo

Ward 1 councillor Dan Gibson says council has to take the heat for a potential budget increase well above the rate of inflation.

Initial budget submissions show a tax supported city budget increase of 3.93 per cent over last year. For a home assessed at $400,000, that would mean a property tax increase of $157.

But Gibson said don't blame city staff. He said the reason it is so high (council won't finalize the budget until March 5) is because of decisions made by council.

"I'm just expressing my concerns over what I'm seeing and observing early in the budget process," Gibson said in an interview.

He said since the proposed 3.93 per cent increase was announced there seems to be "a bit of a temptation" for council to "back away" from the proposed budget and let staff take the "ire of the public."

"I feel like we should be reminding the public that it's our staff that's delivered rate of inflation-based budget increases and surpluses for the past three years. That's a very important message for the public to understand," Gibson said.

"Our executive team and our staff are performing well delivering us budget surpluses and bringing us budget increases that are in line with inflation. These are council decisions that are driving this budget up," Gibson said.

What has pushed the increase up, Gibson said, are decisions made by council in 2018 that have implications on the 2019 budget.

"It's really council's in-year spending that's driving up this budget," Gibson said.

This year's proposed budget increase includes $2.2 million that were caused by decisions made by council in 2018, including the decision to cancel paid on-street parking ($600,00) and restoring more frequent bus service to the city's least-utilized bus route ($175,000).

"We should really be receiving a 2.93 per cent budget request, but instead we're really receiving an almost 4 per cent increase," Gibson said.

"We're not getting to the root causes of why the budget is going up. There's this false dichotomy that's occurring that to address housing and homelessness, we hae to have huge tax increases. That's simply not true."

He took to Twitter on Sunday to express his concerns, which led to an exchange with Mayor Cam Guthrie over Twitter, as the mayor attempted to put some perspective on the numbers contained in Gibson's tweet.


Gibson and the Twitter exchange with the mayor was nothing more than positive discussion on something that both care about and not a disagreement.